Maple Films
  • About
    • Contact
    • Donate
    • Press
  • Our Films
    • 20th Century Man
    • Abroad
    • The Astronomer
    • Early October
    • The House of Boredom
    • Mind Over Manners
    • Super Pimp
    • Transistor
    • Undue Process
  • Other Videos
    • The History of NASA
    • The Killers- War Movie Montage
    • Iceception
    • Ultimate Movie Montage
  • J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit
    • FAQ
    • Downloads
    • An Unexpected Journey Edits
    • The Desolation of Smaug Edits
    • Battle of Five Armies Edits
    • Video Clips
  • Rogue One Fanedit
    • Rogue One Downloads
    • Video Clips

New Clip: The end of durin's Line

3/30/2015

18 Comments

 
After a good amount of brainstorming, I was able to combine the deaths of Kili and Fili into a single scene. I was really afraid of editing the Ravenhill sequence because of this issue specifically, but I'm very happy with how it turned out. Let me know what you think!

JRR Tolkien's The Hobbit: The End of Durin's Line from Dustin Lee on Vimeo.

18 Comments
Ian
3/30/2015 05:44:25 am

This isn't The Hobbit that we need, but the one we deserve.

This is excellent editing and I'm really looking forward to the final fan edit!

Reply
Dustin
3/30/2015 05:49:50 am

Bruce Wayne approves this comment.

Reply
zolee
3/30/2015 07:47:17 am

One word: masterful.

Reply
Sandro
3/30/2015 08:17:35 am

Nice one! It's a really creative edit to splice them together. Is there perhaps a way you could show Azog dropping Fili from the tower? His corpse lying on the ground with open eyes was one of the things I found very chilling. I know it might be hard to do since Kili is standing down there. Maybe it will work in this version, maybe it won't... But I'm already happy!

Reply
TCZ
3/30/2015 09:17:00 am

I really love this! Its great how you got around kili's death without including tauriel. I think you could remove tauriel even more. Just take out that whole look back after kili jumps in his barrel, and take out the shot of her seeing the trap door close when Bilbo falls into the river. Love what I've seen and looking forward to the edit! Also, I think showing the dwarves in lake town is better than trying but imply they are off screen at the lonely mountain when they clearly aren't

Reply
franklapidus4ever
3/30/2015 09:31:27 am

Very nicely done! Although I do agree with a previous comment about possibly including Azog dropping Fili's body off the cliff. As it stands right now, Fili just kind of disappears.

Reply
Dustin
3/30/2015 12:02:31 pm

You and Sandro make a good point. I'll go back and see if I can add Fili falling off the cliff. It shouldn't be too difficult.

Reply
Dustin
3/31/2015 01:26:46 pm

Yes it will be released via a download link, and very soon. As in the next day or so!

Reply
Denzel Caragos
3/30/2015 08:10:33 pm

Dustin... Your editing skills are simply PRECIOUS!!! :D I do agree with the above comments about Fili disappearing... Maybe show Azog let go of him > cut to Bolg dropping Kili on the ground > then cut to Fili's open-eyed corpse. However, it is undeniable that the current edit is excellently done! I have no doubt regarding the greatness of the final product! Bravo! :)

Reply
Dustin
3/30/2015 09:58:26 pm

OK, so I tried to insert the shots of Fili being dropped and the closeup of his corpse. However it didn't work well because:

1.) When Fili is dropped you can clearly see Kili below him
2.) We never see Fili hit the ground- only Kili's reaction as he lands in front of him. Without an impact it's visually confusing.
3.) Fili's dead closeup is very quick and was actually shot tastelessly. The camera pushes into his face handheld like a 1990s "extreme sports" commercial. It just looks odd.

So for this version of the fanedit, I'm afraid I'll have to leave it as is. But hopefully the EE will give us more to work with...

Reply
Denzel Caragos
3/31/2015 12:31:18 am

Good point. Ditto on the EE's additional footage. Here's to a satisfying wrap up to the Wilderland storyline later this year! :)

Josh
3/30/2015 11:15:28 pm

I have to say, this is shaping up to look really great! Do you think your going to release your cut before the EE comes out, or are you waiting until it's completely done?

Reply
Dustin
3/30/2015 11:24:57 pm

Thank you! I will release a version of the fanedit very soon. It will be completely finished aside from color correction and the additional EE scenes from the third film. I expect this early release can hold people over until later this year!

Reply
franklapidus4ever
3/31/2015 12:40:43 pm

How will it be released again? A download link?

Andrei341989
4/1/2015 01:36:37 am

I already have the LotR blu-ray extended edition. Hot popcorn/coke and plenty of pizzas to last throught the night. Even bought the Hobbit Trilogy (to make this whole thing legal). I also talked with some friends to make a middle-earth marathon. The only thing missing is your edit. We are waiting patiently. :D

bn_filmz
4/18/2015 10:15:18 pm

This re-edited scene doesn't work.

It's quite clear, that Thorin isn't looking at Kili, cause when the camera looks UP, we only see Azog with Fili (and a few other orcs). We don't see Bolg and Kili, but Thorin is supposed to be able to see Kili and Bolg - how else could he react to Kili's death? It's not clear where Kili and Bolg are located. And there is nothing about the geography of those scenes that can justify the idea of Bolg and Kili being upthere with Azog and Fili. And therefore those inserted shots of Kili being killed by Bolg don't work - they are just awkward and misplaced.

Besides that: When Thorin shouts "Kili!", he sounds like he wants Kili to stop or wait for him. It doesn't sound like a sorrowful cry; that is: like Kili is dead. (His grief over Fili's death is expressed through his tearful eyes and his gasp moments before he yells after Kili.)

But my comment will probably be deleted very soon, cause Dustin Lee doesn't like to be criticized. On the discussion boards he calls me "delusional", simply because I love the Hobbit films and regard them as masterpieces ... in order words: because I don't share his opinion.

I would never call HIM "delusional" - all I can say, is that he has a different opinion and a different taste than me, and that alright. I don't understand why he thinks, it's necessary to be arrogant and patronizing towards people, who disagree with him.

Reply
Dale Pease link
5/24/2015 07:20:52 am

Well, I didn't see the BotFA at all. I just couldn't bring myself to do it after the disappointment with the first two. So I've not seen any of this footage yet, and I think it flows great. I can't wait for the whole thing to be complete in the fall. Then I can see the movie I hoped to see in the first place.

Reply
Dustin
5/25/2015 02:10:18 am

The third film required the most amount of work for me, editing-wise. Watching BOTFA in theaters felt like I was watching a rough cut that wasn't even ready. I believe the Extended Edition comes out Nov. 3rd, so I'll have the final version of my fanedit shortly after that!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About

    This page is dedicated to my ongoing fanedit project for The Hobbit trilogy, titled J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit. The plan is to edit three mediocre films into one (hopefully) excellent film. Click here to jump straight to the Downloads Page.

    Archives

    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    links

    An Unexpected Journey Edits
    Desolation of Smaug Edits
    Video Clips

    RSS Feed

©2016 Maple films ltd.
all rights reserved
✕